New Jersey Wants to Make Criticizing Islam a Crime — the First Amendment Has Thoughts

New Jersey Wants to Make Criticizing Islam a Crime — the First Amendment Has Thoughts

Assembly Bill A1146, introduced by Assemblyman Joe Danielsen, a Democrat representing New Jersey's 17th district, would formally define "Islamophobia" in state law and create a framework for punishing speech that falls under that definition. Not violent threats. Not incitement. Criticism.

The Bill of Rights turned 235 years old in 1791. Apparently New Jersey thinks it's expired.

The bill doesn't create equal protection for all religions. It doesn't establish a universal anti-blasphemy standard. It carves out a special legal category for one faith — Islam — that Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism, and every other religion on earth does not receive. Danielsen's legislation treats skepticism of Islamic doctrine as a form of bigotry rather than what the First Amendment has always protected it as: speech.

The late Justice Antonin Scalia made the relevant point years ago when he observed that the Constitution is not a guarantee to not be offended. Scalia understood something Danielsen apparently doesn't: discomfort is not harm, and the government has no business deciding which discomforts qualify for prosecution.

Britain already ran this experiment. In 2021, Britain's Court of Appeal had to intervene in cases where police were recording "non-crime hate incidents" — logging legal speech as quasi-offenses on citizens' records. The backlash was severe enough that by March 2026, the UK government announced plans to replace the entire non-crime hate incident system. They built the speech-policing apparatus, watched it consume resources and civil liberties in equal measure, and are now trying to dismantle it.

Danielsen looked at that wreckage and thought: we should try this in Trenton.

The structural problem with A1146 isn't just constitutional — it's logical. The bill requires the state to define what constitutes legitimate criticism of Islam versus impermissible "Islamophobia." That means a government body gets to decide which theological objections are acceptable and which cross the line. The same progressives who insist on separation of church and state now want the state to referee doctrinal disputes — but only for one church.

As Daily Wire columnist and commodities fund manager Brad Schaeffer noted, the principle attributed to Evelyn Beatrice Hall still applies: "I disapprove of what you say, but will defend to the death your right to say it." That sentiment used to be a liberal bumper sticker. Now it's a conservative legal argument, because the left abandoned it the moment speech they disliked entered the conversation.

Every religion in America operates under the same deal. You're free to practice. Others are free to disagree. The government stays out. That arrangement has worked since 1791 precisely because it doesn't play favorites. A1146 plays favorites.

The same legislators who've spent years mocking evangelical Christians, calling religious conservatives bigots, and treating Catholic judicial nominees as suspects now want the force of law behind the idea that one specific religion cannot be questioned. They didn't discover tolerance. They discovered a constituency.

Assemblyman Danielsen's bill sits in committee. The First Amendment sits in the Constitution. One of them has seniority.


Most Popular

Most Popular